The Curious Case of the Dirty Reds

Image

On January 9th 1908 the second Sydney Rugby League team was created. Before the Tigers were formed at Balmain Town Hall, before the Rabbitohs gathered in Redfern, and before Paddington Town Hall announced that the Eastern Suburbs Region would participate in the newly formed competition, the Glebe District Rugby League Football Club was formed.

They would fall by the way side in less than 25 years, like so many other teams both before and after them, but none has quite the unique story that the Dirty Reds do.

Growing up, I didn’t have avenues such as Wikipedia, or even the internet, to allow me to research all of the topics I found interesting. The internet wasn’t a big thing until around the time I finished High School. Wikipedia didn’t exist until 3 years after I finished High School and it didn’t reach a total of 1 million articles until 8 years after I finished High School (there’s currently over 4 times that many articles on Wikipedia). Consequently, I am still catching up on all the things I would have wasted my youth learning about* and in researching my highly indulgent last article, I finally got a chance to look into the early days of the NSWRL.

My vague childhood memories of those early teams included Glebe, as well as Cumberland, Newcastle, Annandale and University. But in my mind they were all there in 1908, were all rubbish and in turn all left the comp within the first few years. That description is accurate for some of the clubs, but for Glebe I was well off the mark.

Cumberland won a single game in their history and left the competition after just one season. Newcastle, lasted a total of 20 matches over 2 seasons with a winning percentage of 45%. Annandale weren’t there from the very beginning (joining in 1910) but somehow managed to last for 11 seasons in spite of winning only 25 of their 153 matches, including 2 entirely winless seasons. University started in 1920 and astoundingly got through 18 seasons that included 12 wooden spoons. They had one small spot of success in 1926 when they finished as runners up, but followed it up by finishing in last place the following season. They have the record for most consecutive losses in NSWRL/NRL history with  42 and they in fact only won 2 games in their last 4 seasons in the competition**

Those are the other folded teams of the Pre-WWII era. You can probably understand why I had lumped them all in together as a bunch of awful teams that the competition was better off without.

Then there’s Glebe.

They obviously participated in the first season back in 1908, sitting in a three way tie for first position on the ladder heading in the final game of the season against next door neighbours Balmain. They lost that final match and finished the season in third. For some reason the finals format that season had them playing the first placed Rabbitohs in a knockout semi-final, whilst the second placed Roosters got to play 4th placed North Sydney. Glebe had beaten Eastern Suburbs (11-5) in their only encounter of the season – and it was the only game that the Roosters lost all year. Unfortunately the Dirty Reds were not good enough to beat South Sydney and missed out on a place in the first ever Grand Final, but if it weren’t for this scheduling quirk, they may have played at the Agricultural Showground at Moore Park on the last Saturday of August 1908.

The following 2 years saw Glebe drop off into 5th place on both occasions, but 1911 was a big year as they finished the regular season with the minor premiership after 11 wins and 3 losses as well as both the league’s best attack and defence. This was due in no small part to the emergence of the teenage sensation and one of the greatest players ever to play the game – Frank Burge.

Image

Burge made his Rugby League debut for Glebe that year as a 16 year old Second Rower. Think about that. A 16 year old second rower. He scored 7 tries that season, but what’s even more amazing is that he had switched codes at the start of the year from Rugby Union – where he started playing first grade two years earlier at age 14! Burge was named on the bench in the Rugby League Team of the Century in 2008 and he was quite simply a phenomenon.

Burge turned 17 about a month before Glebe took on Eastern Suburbs in the Grand Final that year and it took another great of the game – Dally Messenger – to deny Glebe their first ever Premiership win.

In 1912 Glebe were denied their chance for revenge. They finished the year in second place behind the Roosters however the rules were changed so that the team that finished the season on top of the ladder were declared the Premiers automatically and a final was only to be played if two teams finished on equal points. If this had been in place the season before, Glebe would have been the Premiers.

1913 saw Glebe slip to 4th place (which is still respectable, and downright outstanding compared to the other teams mentioned in this article) in the league, but managed to win the City Cup, a tournament played at seasons end, to give them their first real silverware.

1915 was the real emergence of Frank Burge as Glebe finished the season in second place again and the now 20 year old forward finished the season as the top try scorer with 20 tries – in just 14 games.

1916 saw Glebe finish 1 point off top spot with by far the league’s best attack as Frank Burge continued to grow into the statistical anomaly that defined his career, this season scoring 22 tries in the 14 games played.

1918 had Frank Burge breaking his own try-scoring record, this time with 24 tries in 14 matches, but Glebe were once again just off the pace in third spot.

In 1920 Frank Burge was the leading point scorer in the competition as he took on goal kicking duties as well as setting the still standing record for most tries in a game with 8. That’s right, 8. But they only managed to finish in 3rd spot – the same position they would finish for the shortened 1921 season. They had proven to be a good team, but not quite the best.

The 1922 season was the longest season yet at 16 matches and Glebe finished on equal points with the North Sydney Bears at the conclusion of the regular season, which under the aforementioned rules meant that they would be pitted against each other in a Grand Final match to determine the Premiership. North Sydney had won the Premiership the previous season and rode their momentum through to a thorough Grand Final victory over the Dirty Reds and Glebe were once again denied their maiden premiership.

In 1926, the finals series was brought back to life with the top four teams going through to the finals. Glebe finished in second place and took on the perennial easy beats University in the knockout semi-final. As fate would have it, University would win their first and only ever semi-final match comfortably against Glebe, who had now written their own narrative as always being the bridesmaid, but never the bride.

In their last 3 seasons in the competition (1927-29) Glebe would spend most of their time battling to avoid the wooden spoon, which they did manage to do. A small feat, yes, but it meant that they finished their existence without ever ending the season in last place.

To recap, they finished 22 regular seasons with the following placements –
1st – 1 time
2nd – 4 times
3rd – 5 times  (That’s already 10 times out of 22 attempts that they were in the top three)
4th – 3 times (Given that 11 of the seasons they played had 8 teams and 11 had 9 teams this gives them a total of 13 finishes in the top half of the table or about 60%)
5th – 4 times (One of these times they were stripped of 2 points which would have seen them finish 3rd)
6th – 2 times (The first of which didn’t happen until their 16th season)
7th – 1 time
8th – 2 times
9th – 0 times

That is a record that I think a lot of teams would take even if you weighted the positioning to adjust for the extra sides that are now in the competition. The Cowboys have been around for almost as long as Glebe existed now (this is their 18th season) and if you could give their supporters a choice between their current record (On the brink of just their 6th top half finish with 1 Grand Final loss and 3 wooden spoons) or give them Glebe’s results from their first 18 seasons (12 top half finishes with 2 Grand Final losses and no wooden spoons) I know which one they’d be choosing, and the Cowboys are considered a fairly successful team in terms of their on-field performance.

Image

So what happened?

Wikipedia mentions rumours of a conspiracy in voting that forced them out of the competition, with an alleged deal being done between Balmain and Souths to rid the competition of Glebe and consolidate their respective territories. However this doesn’t really make sense. Obviously I would expect that Balmain would absorb some of Glebe’s territory, but Sydney University would surely also gain territory as well as Newtown being between the South Sydney and Glebe boundaries meaning that an agreement with Souths would not make sense from the Rabbitohs perspective.

As you can imagine, first-hand accounts from that time are few and far between, so I did what any person would do in my search for Rugby League knowledge.

I asked David Middleton, who (of course) was a phenomenally useful wealth of information on the subject.

It all started back in the 1917 season when Glebe were docked 2 points for fielding a player who was not residentially qualified to be playing for them (Dan Davies). Back then, to play for any club, you had to be living within their boundaries. There were no salary caps and very little in the way of mercenary behaviour from players because signing for a new team would require moving your whole family to the other end of the city, which wasn’t as simple back then as it is now. Dan was a former Newcastle player from their earlier seasons and he moved to Sydney and was quickly brought in by Glebe. He had to live in the Glebe area for 28 days before he was eligible, however Davies was technically living in Annandale which is a bordering suburb of Glebe. But that was not enough. Much like the maligned Adam Banks*** in the Mighty Ducks series, the borders were the borders for a reason and he was playing for the wrong team. They may have even gotten away with it (at least for a while) if they didn’t rush him into the team immediately following his required 28 days of residence to make his debut against – you guessed it – Annandale. Glebe disagreed with the ruling of the NSWRL hierarchy to strip the 2 premiership points off them and it led to a player strike later in the season and completely derailed what was a promising season until then, as they won only 2 of their remaining 6 games after this. The ‘rebel’ players were initially threatened with life bans but were re-instated before the beginning of the 1918 season, except for Dan Davies who did receive a life ban from playing Rugby League in Australia.

It was the beginning of what would be an ongoing war between Glebe and the League – a war which could only ever be won by one party.

There were disputes over the use of Glebe’s home ground at Wentworth Park**** and the departure of their top administrator (CHJ Upton) in 1920 seems to have exacerbated the situation leaving communications between the club and the league at an all-time low.

Glebe felt that a strong bias had grown against their players when it came to judiciary matters and an attempt to stage a testimonial match for the great Frank Burge in 1923 was met by the NSWRL putting on counter attractions to deny the club of a strong revenue stream from the match.

But it wasn’t all one sided. Glebe was awfully mismanaged through the 1920’s. There is a letter from a Glebe supporter that is held in the JC Davis Sporting collection at the NSW State Library that attests to delegates living out of the district (contrary to NSWRL regulations), an absence of quality coaching and a lack of action by officials over matters important to the club.

In the wash up of all of this, Glebe were a targeted team who, once results went south, were no longer worth the trouble that they were causing the NSWRL.

It is believed that from about 1927 “Balmain’s rugby league delegates had been quietly working towards Glebe’s elimination so the Balmain club could acquire Glebe’s territory in their efforts to recapture their old glories” according to author Max Solling. Of course this work would require garnering some support from the other clubs to turf the Dirty Reds. What Balmain offered in return for the rival clubs’ support is not clear, but it is believed that the targeted teams were Newtown, Easts and Souths.

There were 25 votes on the NSWRL Boundaries Revision Committee which were comprised of 2 delegates from each of the 9 teams along with the 7 members of the league executive. It could be counted on that the 7 league executive members would be voting against keeping Glebe in the competition, meaning that along with Balmain, only two clubs needed to be convinced of the advantages of voting against Glebe’s continued involvement. Nobody knows how each club officially voted, but in the end Balmain got their way, with the vote finishing 13-12 against Glebe. So while the Tigers may have instigated the final nail it was a coffin that the Dirty Reds management seem to have built for themselves.

In the end, what could have been the story of a successful team on the field, ended up being the story of a club that couldn’t get its act together off it. It’s probably a timely reminder to clubs like the Sharks (and others) that getting their house in order should be the first priority, because as Glebe has shown us, no matter your record on the premiership table, you’re a long time dead.

 

 

 

 

*Instead I wasted my youth listening to Rage Against The Machine and NoFX albums, learning every line of dialogue from The Simpsons, trying to play guitar, and getting drunk – in some order. Probably that one.

**They got the wooden spoon in 8 of their last 9 seasons. But they were amateur students playing against the big boys. You can’t really blame them for being so abysmal all the time.

***Cake eater

****What I wouldn’t give for a nice 25,000 seat stadium at Wentworth Park today. If Glebe were still around I think this would be a possibility, and would also have to be a huge chance to be Sydney FC’s home ground as well.

Overhaul

Image

My proposed next article on what the NRL would look like now if it started out of Brisbane has been put on hold to address the issue that everyone seems to be talking about in NRL circles right now.

The scheduling of the State of Origin.

It seems that almost anyone involved with the game has an opinion on what needs to be done to fix the Origin scheduling, and the only thing that everyone seems to agree on is that the current set up is not the way to go. Except for the TV networks of course, the people who really run the game.

In my opinion, if we are going to fix the State of Origin scheduling, we need to fix the entire competition’s scheduling. From pre-season to the internationals, there’s always room for improvement.

Here is my overall fix. (disclaimer, there are going to be many flaws here. I’m literally thinking about this all for the first time right now just to prove how little thought it takes to find some improvements. Just deal with it)

 

So currently we have an NRL season that starts in the second weekend of March and ends in the first weekend of October. That’s a total of 31 weekends to fit in a 26 round season (where each team only plays 24 matches), a finals series, a State of Origin series and any other representative fixtures that may be played.

I’m happy to keep the season at 31 weeks and still fit all of that in, and I’ll do my best to make the proposal reasonable for the TV networks that really run the game. I’ll also base all of my proposals on this current year’s calendar so that it can be directly compared to how this season has run.

My first proposal is to scrap the Anzac Test. It is a complete waste of time that nobody is interested in, it comes at an inopportune time for Australia to have an international and we already have other Rugby League traditions that can be and are played on Anzac Day.

My second proposal is that we keep the City v Country game, but it is not seen as a legitimate origin selection trial. It is to be played by those people that have NOT made Origin selection. I’ll expand on this when I get to it.

With that out of the way, my initial proposal is that we play the first 12 rounds of the competition completely uninterrupted.

The end of Round 12 would come on Monday the 27th of May. It is the halfway point of the season (as each team only actually plays 24 matches a season, this new season would only have 24 rounds) and gives sides a full half season to get their act together, build combinations, see what is working and what isn’t working etc. On this day BOTH the NSW and QLD State of Origin teams are to be named and they’ll head off to camp the next day.

On Tuesday the 28th of May the “mid-season transfer window” would open (MSTW). During the MSTW, players and teams are able to come to agreements to release players to play elsewhere and players can have their contracts registered with their new teams etc. This whole players-moving-mid-season thing is not what I’d like to see, but given that it is inevitable and is commonly used in sports all around the globe, it’s about time we got with the world sporting program and just embraced it and put some restrictions around it so that it can be done fairly and sensibly.

The weekend starting Friday the 31st of May would be our representative weekend.

It would start on the Friday night with a City v Country match to be played in a countryish town that is a little less remote and a little more populated than some of the towns we have been playing it at lately. I’m talking between Newcastle and Coffs Harbour sized places.  NSW seems intent on going with these “emerging origin” squads to try and earmark potential NSW players, and I think that should be the purpose of this game as opposed to the fraudulent origin selection trial that it is supposed to be now. The starting sides are to be picked by the NSW Coach and selectors, with the 4 man benches to be selected by the respective City and Country coaches. This is the Channel Nine Friday Night game.

The Saturday (1st of June) would consist of representative matches between emerging nations. Start with Samoa v Tonga like the match from earlier this year (preferably without the pitch invasions) and we could go with Fiji v Papua New Guinea for another match. The two winners then play off against each other the following Saturday (8th June) to decide the Emerging Nations Cup™. The Saturday would also have an under 20’s state of origin match and a NSW Cup v QLD Cup representative match. These games would all be covered by Fox Sports and starting with a match at Midday, there could easily be 4 matches covered in a Super Saturday marathon. As this is during the MSTW it would give astute teams a chance to scout some of the top junior talent as well as those players on the fringe of first grade that might be looking for an opportunity to get some first grade football and make some offers to improve their team in the back end of the season.*

Image

The Sunday afternoon blockbuster would be England v NZ in NZ. England has more and more players playing in the NRL meaning that there are less travel issues for the side and it gives both England and NZ a deserved and more meaningful international match to play. As it currently stands the Kangaroos have won the last 12 Anzac Tests. NZ and Australia both get nothing out of it. NZ v England would be a closer fought match as a one off and the Australians are better off playing in Origin as it is a higher quality game. Everyone wins. This would be Channel Nine’s Sunday Afternoon game.

Origin is to be kept on a Wednesday. This is the one part of Origin that isn’t broken. It rates well, the crowds show up, and it’s been tried on other nights but has come back to the Wednesday for a reason. But all three matches are to be played on consecutive Wednesdays.

Origin one would be played on Wednesday the 5th of June (3 days after the Eng v NZ game), Origin two on Wednesday the 12th of June and Origin three on Wednesday the 19th of June.

The MSTW would close on Friday the 14th of June ensuring there are no player distractions from any Origin decider and making sure that all teams are settled at least a week before the second half of the competition kicks off.

Round 13 of the NRL would then kick off on Friday the 21st of June, just 2 days after the final Origin. Some teams would be hampered by players backing up (or not backing up) but it’s only one week and nobody is completely ruled out like they are when taken away to camp in the lead up to Origin currently.

Round 24 would finish on Sunday the 8th of September (no Monday game) which is the same as this season. The teams all get a 3 weekend break in the middle of the season. Origin players don’t, but that’s no different to now. The TV networks (who really run the game) have to make do with no games for 2 weekends, but the momentum built during origin, as well as the higher interest generated in round 13 after the break** compared to the way everyone loses interest during the arduous 8 week Origin period now would come out as a net win for them.

I’m happy to leave the 4 week finals system as it is (though I’m sure I’ll find a fault in it if Souths get knocked out before the Grand Final this year) and the title is decided on Sunday the 6th of October.

We then need to ramp up the end of season internationals. The RLIF needs to be far more proactive (what do they actually do besides give out the Golden Boot award?) in organising internationals in the off season. We need tiers for these national teams to play in and ways for them to move up into higher tiers or drop down to lower ones. Something similar to how the Davis Cup works in Tennis could work or in a perfect world, the system I’m going to put below. But ultimately, there needs to be internationals played for 5 weeks at the end of each season on different levels to allow smaller nations to improve and move up the ladder.

Currently the international teams can be broken into 5 tiers.

Top Tier (Australia, NZ, England)

Second Tier (France, Wales, PNG)

Emerging Nations (Fiji, Samoa, Ireland, Tonga, Scotland)

Developing Nations (USA, Italy, Russia, Serbia, Lebanon, Cook Islands, Germany, Canada)

The Rest (Norway, Malta, Jamaica, Ukraine, South Africa, Latvia, Czech Republic, Denmark)

These are all based on the current international points system, so if you disagree, take it up with the RLIF.

For the Top Tier – first 3 weeks a round robin, week 4 a final, week 5 the bottom team plays off against the top team from the tier below with the result deciding promotion/relegation

For the Second Tier – first 3 weeks a round robin, week 4 a final, week 5 the winner plays the lowest place team from the tier above with the result deciding promotion/relegation, the loser plays the top team from the tier below with the result deciding promotion/relegation

Emerging Nations – A knockout competition that splits in both directions so that after 4 weeks we have an order of first to last in this tier. That is that all the winners of the first round advance, but all the losers also have to play each other as well. Top team plays bottom team from tier above with the result deciding promotion/relegation. Bottom team plays the top team from the tier below with the result deciding promotion/relegation.

Image

Developing Nations – As above

The Rest – Just a straight knockout competition with the winner playing the bottom placed team from the tier above and the result deciding promotion/relegation.

Nobody cares about international Rugby League because NOBODY cares about international Rugby League. Not even the people that are supposed to. If more effort is put into it, we’ll all get more out of it.

I would start the internationals after a week off after the Grand Final, so 5 weeks from the weekend starting Saturday 19th of October through until Saturday the 16th of November for the few nations that play the full 5 weeks.

Those said internationals can then still have their 4 weeks of annual leave that they have earned and be back at Pre Season Training on Monday the 16th of December.

 

That’s my proposal. Is it perfect? Certainly not. Is it exhaustive? Definitely.

Can you do better? Probably.

Let me know your ideas.

 

 

 

 

*I’m well aware that there would have to be an entire system put in place to account for how clubs/players are able to switch teams and how their contracts work etc, but I really don’t have the time or space to do that here, and it is so far from being a reality it’s just not worth it.

**Have no doubts that this is exactly what would happen. There was a massive bump in viewers and attendances after just one weekend without NRL matches this year. Factor in the interest from teams having new players and this is a no brainer.